(10-22-2023, 12:29 AM)putnam6 Wrote:(10-21-2023, 10:13 PM)gortex Wrote: Human Rights investigators analysing the available data from the Hospital strike say indications from doppler sound tracking analysis from the video of the strike indicated the missile came from the East and not West as claimed by the IDF , imagery of the crater seems to back that analysis up , analysis of the audio of the alleged conversation between the two militants released by the IDF as part of their "evidence" is of two different conversations edited together using an audio workstation.
Hey, Gortex good to see you here...
Wasn't the original "official" portrayal the missile hit the hospital directly it was destroyed and there were 500 deaths of innocent Gazans?
I say this with the complete realization that the proportionality here is out of whack , while understanding Israel is still getting attacked for Hezbollah and elsewhere as well as launches from within Gaza. All the while only 2 hostages have been released.
You can't hold innocent civilians while shooting missiles and attacking on all sides and expect Israel to stand down. It can't be shown that anybody gets a reprieve when you kidnap and take civilians hostage. Again I don't agree with the proportionality but I understand where this has put Israel at.
Hi Putnam , thanks for the welcome.
At the time of the strike the unofficial report from those at the scene was the missile hit the car park where civilians were sheltering which would seem to be the case , Israel said it was a failed rocket launch by terrorists which like other claims they've made would seem not to be the case if the claims in the video are correct.
Personally I think Israel are where they want to be , not sure they're that interested in the hostages as their deaths bolster Israel's position.
As you know I've taken much heat at the other place over this but I'm only calling it as I see it , I'm not anti semitic I'm anti war but this war seems to me to be a war of opportunity on Israel's part , or more specifically Netanyahu and his unpopular Far Right government , I see little proportionality but much crimes against humanity with the West seemingly happy to ignore war crimes taking place in Gaza , our governments have blood on their hands too.